<From the Pish Page- Mystery Creek


 

June, 16 2002 Mystery Creek

Time: 8:30am - 12:15pm
Weather: Sunny and Clear
Water Temps: ?
Water Level: High
Water Conditions: Clear and slightly weedy.
Insects Observed: Midges, Small Mayflies
Hours fished: 4
# of fish caught: 8 landed out of ?

Narrative:

The fly fisher as predator.  There’s something very satisfying about declaring that you are going to go to bring back dinner and actually doing it. I know, this flies in the face conventional PC Fly Fishing etiquette. I’ve never put much stock in that hunter/gather, getting back to our roots, maintaining our traditions mumbo jumbo that hunters often espouse  but there’s something primal about planning to fish your limit and actually doing it; something that touches our primitive self and is immensely satisfying. Chest swelling satisfying.

Today on Mystery Creek, I planned to kill five fish, did and am feeling pretty good about it. The fishing started innocently enough. I had 2 1/2 hours to creel 5 dinner fish. Didn’t seem too difficult at first but when in the first hour I had only landed 2 fish, barely large enough to feed a cat, my skills as provider fell into question. In truth, I started to feel slightly stressed. What must it have been like to HAVE to catch fish to feed your family I wondered. Realizing for the first time that what I take for granted as a simple pleasure was a necessity for folks 100 years ago and is a necessity for many South East Asian immigrants today.

I can remember when I first started fly fishing. I would cut class to fish Lake Temiscal in the evenings. Fishing for Bluegill mostly but there were always families of Vietnamese or Laotian immigrants, bait fishing for the latest stockers. A father and his sons mostly, set up with multiple rods. At a limit of 5 fish each, the more sons, the more fish for the family. They were good. I remember standing in awe as this kid made his cast and seconds later pulled in a fish, only to do it again 5 minutes later. It was amazing to watch.

I, of course, wasn’t under nearly the same sort of pressure. The pressure on myself was self-inflicted. In 2 hrs I was meeting my family at a restaurant for Father’s day brunch. Putting food on the table was not a problem, not now, hopefully not ever.

Feeling I had spent too much time fishing the lower river, I moved quickly through areas that are usually fish producers. It was now 11am and I wanted to hit the “big fish” water before my planned 11:30am departure. By this time, I had switch from my Krystal Flash on a Hook, Bead Head Prince combination to a BH Prince, Gold Rib Hares Ear combination. I was getting desperate. I lost faith in my usual sure thing for this stream attractor flies in favor of a “match the hatch” strategy. I quickly surveyed the stream and found bunches of size 20 midge and mayfly nymphs. My first instinct was to put on a size 20 midge imitation but I opted for the more generic GRHE imitation.

It worked. Now at the “big fish” pool, I hooked fish. I soon went from zero to one fish in the creel. On the next cast, I hooked into the biggest fish of the pool. He revealed himself with a slight head turn as I tightened up on my rod. I felt a slight tug and the “twang” you feel when you’ve pulled a fly from a fish’s mouth……I missed the largest fish of the day. “Boy, what an accomplishment it would be to bring him home for supper”, I thought. “Mom and Dad could live on that fish for days”…..lamenting that I wouldn’t be given a second chance, I continued casting. 1 fish in the creel, missed the big fish of the day, I was quickly approaching the point of no return. What’s the point of no return? The latest time at which I calculated I could leave the river and return home with an acceptable margin of tardiness.

The next fish was the big’n. Whether it was the same fish or a different fish, I don’t know. I suspect it was the same fish taking a different fly. It didn’t matter. It was a brick. The fish made one run to around the pool and then sat motionless in the fast moving water. I, my 6’9” rod and 6x tippet sat motionless as well. There was no way I was going to horse this fish. It was simply too heavy. I had quite a quandary. I was in the same situation 4 or so years ago while fishing a lighter rod. Then the fish charged down stream, my rod went limp as a noodle and my tippet snapped. With steely resolve, I promised myself that would not happen again.

The fish was 22 inches if it was an inch. I’m the first to admit though, that in small streams, things tend to be smaller than they appear. My plan was to simply hold on and let the fish tire. It didn’t seem to want to do anything other than hang out, which was fine with me. We both stayed motionless. It made a play for the rock and undercut bank at the end of the pool. I pulled right, steering him into the shallow water near the bank. It swirled, jumping in water just high enough to cover his back. “Whoa, that’s a big fish…”  Then, it jumped again and my tippet snapped as the fish hit the backside of a rock and left a V wake as it ran down stream.

 “Should have followed it down stream, not tried to play it on a long line”, I muttered to myself. The point of no return had come and gone. I was in trouble now. Not literally. I had missed the point of no return and a scolding was inevitable. Not only that but I assured a scolding for years to come. Once, about 10 years ago, I fished Pleasant Valley Creek before my wife and I were due to check out of our hotel. “I’ll be back before check out”, I declared. I returned to find my wife, bags in hand, waiting on the stoop outside our room, not in the best of moods.  For years later, until his death, Don the innkeeper would take a dig at me each time I drove away with rod in hand. He had great fun at my expense.

What’s that expression? “In for a penny, in for a pound?”. I continued to fish, hoping to hook another big fish but knowing that with all the commotion the previous monster had made, I’d be lucky to hook anything.

No one has ever accused hatchery fish of being bright. (What? Did you think these were wild fish?) Within a half dozen casts I was into another fish, then another, and then another. I left only when, after having filled my creel, a half dozen casts didn’t garner any more strikes. It was 12:15 by now. Our planned meeting time was 12:30 and even with good traffic, it would take me an hour to drive back.

I sped by Sunday morning churchgoers and screeched around road toasters returning from Yosemite as I raced into town. I arrived at 1:40pm and met my brother in law just as he was leaving. “How’re are they doing?”, I asked. “Barely started on the second round”, he replied. We both smiled knowingly. The first course at a buffet is just a snack for this group. It’s rare that we get out in under 2 ˝ hours. My wife sat with a big smile on her face and waved me over. I guess I hadn’t reached the point of no return after all.

As we left to return to the Bay Area, my mother-in-law had fish heads simmering on the stove and a big smile. She was pleased with my catch and so was I.

 

Previous Pish Page Chronicle         Next Pish Page Chronicle          Pish Page Index